Part scan: mesh or CAD? What to ask before you pay
Moving one screw hole in a 3D scan is like fixing a typo in a photo of a letter.
Short answer
Mesh files vs CAD files is a choice about your next step: a mesh copies the scanned surface as it is, and editable CAD lets you change the part. Decide before you pay: a mesh to copy a shape as it is, editable CAD to move a hole or change a size. Then put the six questions below to any provider.
Move one hole
The same plate as a mesh and as editable CAD: in the mesh a screw hole is only a ring of triangles, and in editable CAD it is a feature you can move.
A mesh is a skin of many small triangles laid over the surface, so a hole is only the place where the triangles stop. To move it, you push triangles around, which is why it feels like scraping a typo off a photo. In editable CAD the hole has a size and a place, and you change them. You do not need either file to start: LOUEI 3D PRINT can start from the part itself or photos of it.
Under the drawings are six questions to ask before you pay for a scan. They are for any provider, whoever you choose, and most of them turn on one point: is the CAD rebuilt from the scan, or is the mesh only saved as a CAD file type?
Move one hole: mesh or CAD
- Which file: a mesh, editable CAD or both, and in which file type?
- Rebuilt or converted: is the CAD rebuilt from the scan, or is the mesh only wrapped in a CAD file?
- The raw scan: do you get it as well, or does the provider keep it?
- Matched how: what will you be shown, so you can hold the model up against your own part before anything is made?
- Not included: what is left out, and what would cost extra?
- Who owns the files: who keeps the scan and the model, and is that agreed in writing?
Can’t you just convert the STL into a STEP file?
Converting an STL into a STEP file changes the file type, but it can leave the shape as the same small triangles in a different wrapper.
A smooth curve may need thousands of triangles in a mesh, where CAD describes it with a few exact curves. Most CAD programs will import a mesh and save it under a STEP name, and the file will open. One scan-to-CAD firm’s guide warns that such a file still holds no design intent: every flaw of the scan is wrapped, not removed.
Even a real CAD file in a shared format such as STEP can hold exact shapes and still lose the feature history that makes a model easy to change. So ask what you can actually change.
The test is simple. Before you pay, ask to see the hole listed as a hole, a feature you can resize, and not as a ring of triangles. At LOUEI 3D PRINT, scanning work means a scan rebuilt into CAD you can edit, then a replacement made in-house.
When is a mesh all you need?
A cleaned-up mesh is all you need when you want to copy a shape and print it as it is.
3D printers read mesh files, so a mesh can be printed. You need editable CAD when you want to change a size, move a hole or make the part another way, because a mesh has no feature list to edit.
A scanned mesh can also have gaps and open edges that need repair before it is used. So decide what you will do with the file first: asking for editable CAD you will never change may be more than you need. Whether a phone scan is good enough is a question of its own, and another post answers it.
| What you ask about | A mesh (such as an STL) | Editable CAD |
|---|---|---|
| What it is made of | A skin of many small triangles that describes the surface. | Exact shapes and dimensions that you can change one at a time. |
| Moving one hole | Hard to do cleanly: you push triangles around instead of changing a hole. | The hole is a feature: change its size or position. |
| What it suits | Looking at a shape, copying it as it is and printing it. | Changing a size, moving a hole or making the part another way. |
| Scan gaps | A scanned mesh may have gaps and open edges that need repair. | A converted file may still lose the features you wanted to edit. |
Will a scanned copy carry the wear of the old part?
A scan copies the part as it is today, so its wear and warp come along unless the model is rebuilt toward the shape the part was meant to have.
One scan-to-CAD firm’s guide lists wear, warp and scan noise as baked into a mesh, where they cannot be told apart from the intended shape unless a person says which is which. A software maker’s guide draws the same line between a copy of the part as built, flaws and all, and a model of what the designer meant.
Rebuilding means deciding, face by face, whether a surface was meant to be flat, whether a hole now worn oval was meant to be round. The scan alone cannot say. Tell whoever does the work which faces have worn, and keep the part it fits: it shows where the old shape used to meet.
- Chipped corner: a scan keeps the chip.
- Worn hole: oval now, round as designed.
- Rounded rail edge: worn by use, square as designed.
- Dashed lines: the part as it was meant to be; editable CAD can aim there.
A scan copies the part as it is today.
Before you contact any shop
Have these ready. Any shop will ask for most of them.
- Photos: the whole part on plain paper, the same view with a ruler beside it, and the break up close.
- The sizes you can measure, and what the part fits onto or into.
- Where the part lives and what it does.
- How many you need.
- Any file or drawing you have, even an old one.
At LOUEI 3D PRINT you can start from anything: an idea, a sketch, a photo, CAD, measurements, the broken part itself or a previous order. We read STEP, STL, OBJ, IGES, DXF, PDF drawings and photographs.
When this is not a job for a shop
- A scan copies a shape, not what made the part safe: in Canada some vehicle equipment is regulated under the Motor Vehicle Safety Act, so a safety-critical car part is not a casual reprint.
- In BC, gas and mains-powered work is for qualified people working for licensed contractors, so a scanned copy of a part on that side of an appliance is a question for them first.
Some parts cannot be reproduced: parts that are badly damaged, parts with missing geometry, and parts that need a certification we do not hold.
Written by the LOUEI 3D PRINT team. LOUEI 3D PRINT makes custom and replacement parts: 3D scanning and reverse engineering, FDM and resin 3D printing, molding and casting. Serving North America.